It’s usually explained just like the artistic license for the author’s area
Tend to whenever times are given, they are provided with a day of one’s times one really does not meets thereupon date since it during the real record. One particular analogy occurs in Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner out of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney describes 16 Oct given that Monday, though sixteen Oct 1993 are a saturday.
There are even contradictions when you look at the instructions of this type. For example, into the Harry Potter therefore the Cup of Flames, both 1 Sep and you will dos September are supplied because Mondays and you may, in Harry Potter together with Prisoner of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is decided on the 20 April, but mindful parsing of the text message shows that it could have happened no later than simply March.
Plus, during the Harry Potter therefore the Cup away from Flame people say the Winners had been chosen towards Saturday 29 Oct, however, 31 October try a saturday when you look at the 1994.
During the chapter 7 out of Quidditch From the Ages, they claim that the brightwomen.net Ressurser very first Quidditch Industry Glass was held in 1473. In the event your tournament was held every several years, that it issues to your report during the Goblet out of Flames that 1994 World Cup is actually this new 422nd. When the Quidditch From the Age is good, new 422nd Quidditch Community Glass carry out in reality fall-in the season 3161, however if Goblet away from Flames is right, the first Community Cup was held during the 306.
Historical troubles [ ]
Whilst the series, according to schedule produced by the Chamber from Treasures site, is determined on 1990s, new collection often appears as though it is place in the fresh later nineties so you can middle-2000s, about concurrent towards the guide of the guides. Within the Harry Potter additionally the Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a masculine pronoun to refer into “predecessor” of your own Finest Minister of your British. According to the more than timeline, this would occur in the summer out of 1996, in the event the Best Minister are John Major, whose immediate ancestor is actually a woman (is the reason earliest meeting with Fudge, the publication says the new election, however, Significant was not initial decided and only grabbed more once Thatcher resigned.
You will be able, yet not unlikely, you to definitely Fudge will be talking about a more faraway predecessor, while the Thatcher got office ahead of Fudge allegedly turned Minister to have Magic. (Even though it’s possible to think a situation where Fudge is delegated by Minister having Miracle to satisfy toward Best Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller workplace.) At the same time, the newest identity and you will history of the prime Minister depicted appears to far more directly suits that Tony Blair than out-of John Biggest. A post from the Each and every day Post cards one to Rowling is romantic into the following-Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown (will viewed as a competitor so you’re able to Blair’s frontrunners of one’s Labour People, just who succeeded your and you can became Primary Minister), and this she might have been trying to reveal Blair’s terrible top. In the event the books was basically devote sync having guide time out-of Philosopher’s Brick, upcoming that it experiences create occur in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned into Prime Minister).
Yet not, it had been after reported that twenty two November was a saturday, that it was a student in 1994
A comparable condition concerns Nicolas Flamel, who had been stated as being 665 in the course of the new very first publication, but Nicolas Flamel was a bona-fide historical profile and you may wouldn’t have reached that decades until 1996, in the date the initial book is had written. Brand new rebuttal for this is that the time brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel was born doesn’t talk to this new Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.
A separate condition exists regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure given that Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is meant from the collection you to Hagrid gotten one to status within a couple of years of his expulsion away from university from inside the 1942. In one to world out-of Harry Potter therefore the Goblet regarding Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces on Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap having Molly’s many years at school, it appears to be unrealistic one she recalls a past gamekeeper. Yet not, it will be easy that Hagrid failed to become a gamekeeper quickly after being expelled, but rather started as the Ogg’s assistant. This will be probable since the whenever Harry believes which he commonly getting expelled getting flying towards broomstick rather than consent within his first year, the guy miracle when the however be permitted to stick to because Hagrid’s secretary.